Budgeting Is Dead (Do This Instead)

The Big Picture on How Budgeting Works Today:

• • Traditional budgeting often leads to burnout. Instead, focus on building a mindful relationship with money and spending aligned with your values.

  • Whitney Elkins-Hutton categorizes spending into destructive, protective, productive, and consumptive—helping you optimize where your money goes.

  • Tools like Simplifi or Empower let you automate tracking, freeing you from micromanagement while still supporting long-term wealth goals.

Most people hate budgeting. Hate with a capital H. But if you want to build wealth, there’s no getting around one critical truth: you need to grow the gap between what you earn and what you spend. 

That requires being more intentional with your money — and according to Whitney Elkins-Hutton, founder of Ash Wealth and author of Money For Tomorrow: How to Build and Protect Generational Wealth, traditional budgeting isn’t the answer.

In fact, she says budgeting as we know it is dead — and it’s time for a better approach.

The Problem With Traditional Budgeting

The classic advice from financial experts like Dave Ramsey and Suze Orman often involves going line by line through your expenses and cutting wherever you can — skipping the avocado toast, eating out less, slashing grocery bills.

While this strategy can help those who are heavily overspending, it often leads to burnout. Eventually, most people get tired of policing every dollar and give up. It’s like practicing soccer endlessly without ever playing a game — you lose motivation without a sense of real progress.

Whitney argues that the key to wealth isn’t obsessively cutting expenses. It’s mastering the basics consistently and building a strong, conscious relationship with your money.

A Smarter Way to Manage Spending

Instead of creating restrictive budgets, Whitney teaches investors to categorize their expenses into four types:

• • Destructive Expenses: Things that actively erode your wealth, such as excessive credit card fees, addictive shopping habits, or substance abuse. These need to be eliminated entirely. 
  • Protective Expenses: Necessary costs like insurance, legal fees, and taxes that safeguard your assets. These should be optimized but not sacrificed. 
  • Productive Expenses: Spending that actively grows your wealth. If every dollar spent brings at least two dollars back, it’s productive. 
  • Consumptive Expenses: Lifestyle spending — dining out, shopping, travel. This is where most people struggle. 

Rather than simply slashing lifestyle expenses, Whitney introduces the idea of the Happiness Formula.

The idea is simple: your lifestyle spending should support experiences and activities that genuinely make you happy.

By identifying what truly matters — whether it’s travel, hosting friends for dinner, attending concerts, or enjoying nature — you can align your spending with your values. This not only reduces wasteful expenses but makes your financial plan more fulfilling.

(article continues below)

Real estate investments? Awesome.

Being a landlord? Less fun.

Learn how to earn 15%+ on passive real estate investments in our free video course.

Managing Money with a Partner

One of the biggest challenges many face is managing different financial values within a household. Spouses or partners often have conflicting ideas about spending, which can create friction. Whitney recommends having each person independently go through the Happiness Formula exercise.

Ask questions like:

• • What experiences matter most to you? 
  • How do you want to grow personally? 
  • How do you want to give back? 

Sometimes, surface-level expenses (like shopping for clothes) are tied to deeper values (such as wanting to feel confident at work or on dates). Understanding these underlying motivations allows couples to create a joint spending plan that honors both partners’ true priorities.

Automation and Tools

Building wealth shouldn’t rely on sheer willpower. Whitney encourages people to automate the tracking of their income and expenses with tools like Simplifi or Empower (formerly Personal Capital).

Automation makes it easier to stay in touch with your money without micromanaging every decision. The goal isn’t to control every penny — it’s to create a system that supports your long-term wealth-building journey effortlessly.

Need More Help? Check Out Our Free Tools and Calculators

No need to hunker down over your calculator and start pounding numbers. SparkRental provides free calculators for everything you’ll ever need to analyze your finances and real estate investments. 

From rental property cash flow analysis to the BRRRR method and mortgage amortization, our calculators are designed to make complex financial calculations easier so you can make smarter investment decisions. Whether you’re evaluating a new rental property, estimating potential returns, or planning a strategy to scale your portfolio, our free tools take the guesswork out of real estate investing. 

Best of all, these calculators are completely free! No hidden fees, no subscriptions, just powerful tools to help you succeed.  

Ready to crunch the numbers like a pro? Explore our full suite of real estate investment calculators today!

Want to compare investment property loans?

What do lenders charge for a rental property mortgage? What credit scores and down payments do they require?

How about fix-and-flip loans?

We compare the best purchase-rehab lenders and long-term landlord loans on LTV, interest rates, closing costs, income requirements and more.

Join Our Co-Investing Club For Hassle-Free Real Estate Investing

Want to enjoy the potential of passive real estate without having to buy real estate? Invest with our exclusive Co-Investing Club at SparkRental! 

Our unique platform allows members to collaboratively evaluate and invest in diverse real estate opportunities, including private partnerships, notes, syndications, equity funds, and secured debt funds. 

With a minimum investment of just $5,000 per deal, our club removes traditional barriers, giving you access to high-yield real estate ventures that typically require $50,000 to $100,000 for individual investments. 

At SparkRental, our Co-Investing Club prioritizes diversification across various property types and geographic locations throughout the U.S. Our carefully selected investments span multifamily units, mobile home parks, self-storage facilities, short-term rentals, and more, aiming for average annualized returns of 15% or higher on equity investments and 10-12% interest on debt investments. 

Each month, our members join interactive video calls to discuss and vet new opportunities, ensuring everyone has a say. 

Best of all, you don’t need to be an accredited investor to join our club!

Whether you’re a seasoned investor or just starting out, our Co-Investing Club offers a streamlined, community-oriented pathway to passive income and financial growth.

Final Thoughts

Budgeting, in the traditional sense, is outdated. Instead of obsessively cutting costs, it’s time to build a deeper relationship with your money — one that focuses on protecting your future, producing wealth, and spending intentionally on what brings you true happiness.

By mastering the basics, categorizing expenses wisely, and aligning your lifestyle with your values, you can create a path to real, lasting wealth — without the guilt or exhaustion of old-school budgeting.